Cities / Winter Garden
Is Winter Garden, FL safe?
It depends on the neighborhood. Of the 20 Winter Garden neighborhoods we score (average 86/100), 20 are comfortable to walk around with normal awareness. Green means comfortable on foot; red means we would not walk it casually.
Safest neighborhoods in Winter Garden
- 1Lake Butler· Winter GardenLake Butler is a tranquil, affluent suburban community situated on the prestigious Butler Chain of Lakes just south of Winter Garden. Characterized…94Go
- 2Deer Island· Winter GardenDeer Island is an exclusive, luxury lakefront community set on Johns Lake in Winter Garden, Florida. Characterized by expansive single-family…93Go
- 3Independence· Winter GardenLocated in the Horizon West sector of Winter Garden, Independence (also known as Signature Lakes) is a picturesque residential development centered…92Go
- 4Windermere· Winter GardenNestled among the Butler Chain of Lakes and historic citrus corridors west of Orlando, Windermere and Winter Garden blend luxurious lakefront…91Go
- 5South Gotha· Winter GardenSouth Gotha is a quiet, tree-canopied pocket nestled between Winter Garden and Windermere, characterized by sprawling estates, private lakes, and…90Go
All Winter Garden neighborhoods by safety score
Go — 15 areas
Comfortable to walk around, day or evening.
- Lake Butler· Winter GardenLake Butler is a tranquil, affluent suburban community situated on the prestigious Butler Chain of Lakes just south of Winter Garden. Characterized…94Go
- Deer Island· Winter GardenDeer Island is an exclusive, luxury lakefront community set on Johns Lake in Winter Garden, Florida. Characterized by expansive single-family…93Go
- Independence· Winter GardenLocated in the Horizon West sector of Winter Garden, Independence (also known as Signature Lakes) is a picturesque residential development centered…92Go
- Windermere· Winter GardenNestled among the Butler Chain of Lakes and historic citrus corridors west of Orlando, Windermere and Winter Garden blend luxurious lakefront…91Go
- South Gotha· Winter GardenSouth Gotha is a quiet, tree-canopied pocket nestled between Winter Garden and Windermere, characterized by sprawling estates, private lakes, and…90Go
- Gotha· Winter GardenGotha is a historic, oak-canopied community in West Orange County known for its Old Florida charm, lakefront properties, and historic German roots…90Go
- Killarney· Winter GardenBordering Oakland and Lake Apopka, Killarney combines semi-rural lakeside living with suburban convenience. It is internationally known among…89Go
- Summerport Beach· Winter GardenSummerport Beach is a picturesque lakeside neighborhood situated along Lake Speer in southern Winter Garden. It features modern single-family homes…89Go
- Crown Point· Winter GardenCrown Point is a pleasant, tree-shaded residential enclave located immediately north of historic downtown Winter Garden in western Orange County…89Go
- East Beulah· Winter GardenEast Beulah is situated in the southern portion of Winter Garden, Florida, flanked by modern residential subdivisions, orange grove heritage pockets…88Go
- Winter Garden· Winter GardenWinter Garden combines classic small-town Florida charm with a revitalized, brick-paved historic core centered on the West Orange Trail. Visitors…88Go
- Oakland· Winter GardenOakland is a charming small town in West Orange County characterized by ancient moss-draped live oaks, dirt side roads, and upscale lakeside…88Go
- Beulah· Winter GardenBeulah is an established suburban community in Winter Garden featuring a mix of mature homesteads, tree-lined streets, and modern single-family…86Go
- East Crown Point· Winter GardenEast Crown Point is an established, peaceful neighborhood on the eastern flank of Winter Garden characterized by mid-to-upscale residential…86Go
- Ocoee· Winter GardenLocated in West Orange County, the Ocoee and Winter Garden area blends traditional Florida citrus-town heritage with modern suburban growth. Visitors…81Go
Go, stay aware — 5 areas
Fine with normal city awareness.
- Ocoee Commons· Winter GardenEast Ocoee encompasses established suburban residential subdivisions, neighborhood strip malls, and commuter corridors connecting Ocoee and Winter…79Go, stay aware
- Tildenville· Winter GardenTildenville is a leafy, residential community characterized by mature oak canopies, older single-family homes, and modest modern infill near the West…78Go, stay aware
- East Ocoee· Winter GardenEast Ocoee sits along the border of Ocoee and Winter Garden in west Orange County, featuring quiet subdivisions, local parks, and shopping plazas. It…76Go, stay aware
- Harlem Heights· Winter GardenHarlem Heights is a tight-knit, historic East Winter Garden neighborhood featuring modest single-family homes, community parks, and local churches…74Go, stay aware
- Paradise Heights· Winter GardenParadise Heights is an unincorporated residential neighborhood situated between Winter Garden and Apopka along the eastern perimeter of Lake Apopka…71Go, stay aware
Winter Garden safety questions
What is the safest neighborhood in Winter Garden?
Lake Butler scores highest at 94/100, followed by Deer Island (93) and Independence (92).
Is Winter Garden safe to walk at night?
In the 15 green-rated areas, generally yes with normal awareness. None of the areas we score are rated orange or red.
Which Winter Garden areas should visitors be careful in?
No area in our list falls below the yellow band.
How does VibeLoco score Winter Garden neighborhoods?
Each score blends recent reported crime and local news with Census data on income, poverty and housing, refreshed nightly. Walk and bike scores are shown separately.