Is Muttontown safe?
Oyster Bay, New York · safety score updated nightly
Yes — it is one of the safer places in the metro to walk around.
VibeLoco rates Muttontown as “Go”.
What makes up this score?Recent news
Gogo's take on Muttontown
“Go. Muttontown is an exceptionally safe, serene, and affluent Gold Coast village defined by private woodland estates and nature preserves. While virtually crime-free, visitors must rely entirely on a private vehicle to navigate the area's secluded, winding country lanes.”
About the area
Located in the Town of Oyster Bay on Long Island's North Shore, Muttontown is a prestigious enclave known for sprawling estates, equestrian properties, and protected green spaces. Visitors come primarily to explore the expansive trails of the Muttontown Preserve and historic mansion grounds.
- Affluent & Exclusive
- Wooded / Nature-Rich
- Car-Dependent
- Quiet & Secluded
Walking and biking in Muttontown
Walk score: 8/100 · Bike score: 18/100
There are no municipal bike-share stations or dedicated on-road bike lanes, though off-road multi-use and equestrian trails exist inside the Muttontown Preserve.
Reasons to go, and reasons to think twice
Pros
- Virtually nonexistent violent crime rate supported by dedicated village police patrols
- Median household income exceeding $250,000 with exceptionally high homeownership rates and pristine property maintenance
- Abundant natural beauty featuring over 550 acres of contiguous public preserve land
- Quiet, low-density residential setting with virtually no commercial congestion
Cons
- Severe car dependency with no commercial district or walkable retail amenities within village borders
- Narrow, winding roads often lack sidewalks or streetlights, making pedestrian travel hazardous along main thoroughfares
- Occasional isolated property crimes or high-end vehicle thefts reported across Nassau County's North Shore
Homelessness: Visible homelessness is not present in Muttontown due to its strictly residential, low-density zoning and lack of commercial corridors or public transit hubs.
What Muttontown is like at each time of day
- Morning · 5a – 11a
- Peaceful and quiet, with early visitors enjoying scenic nature hikes along the preserve trails.
- Afternoon · 11a – 5p
- Calm and residential, with light vehicle traffic along Route 106 and Northern Boulevard.
- Evening · 5p – 10p
- Extremely tranquil as daylight fades, though lack of street lighting makes country roads dark.
- Late night · 10p – 5a
- Completely silent and dark with minimal activity aside from occasional local police patrols.
Transit, parking and getting around
Muttontown has no direct public transit within its borders. The nearest rail transit is the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) at Syosset or Oyster Bay stations, located about a 10-minute drive away.
Free, ample dedicated parking is available at the Muttontown Preserve and local recreation sites. Street parking along village roads is generally prohibited or restricted.
Things to do in Muttontown
- Hike the wooded trail network and see the historic King Zog estate ruins at Muttontown Preserve
- Tour the historic grounds, formal gardens, and galleries at the Nassau County Museum of Art located nearby
- Walk or cross-country ski along the equestrian and nature paths of Chelsea Mansion
Local favorites
- Muttontown Club · Country Club & Golf Course · 4.6★ (110)A private, historic country club offering championship golf, tennis, and dining on scenic estate grounds.
- Arata Sushi · Japanese Restaurant · 4.7★ (280)A top-rated, nearby dining destination serving creative specialty rolls and fresh omakase.
- Heritage Farm · Equestrian Facility · 4.8★ (45)A premier local stable and equestrian facility offering riding training and boarding.
Neighborhoods near Muttontown
Common questions about Muttontown
Is Muttontown safe to walk at night?
Generally yes — use the same awareness you would anywhere after dark.
Is Muttontown a good place to live?
On safety, Muttontown scores 96/100 — safer than most of the areas we score, which is a good start for anyone looking to live here.
How walkable is Muttontown?
Walk score 8/100 and bike score 18/100. Most trips need a car.
Which areas near Muttontown are safer?
Muttontown scores as high as or higher than its closest neighbors.
Add this score to your site
Writing about Muttontown? Copy this code to show its live safety score on your blog or listing.