Is North Bay Shore safe?
Islip, New York · safety score updated nightly
Mostly yes, with normal city awareness.
VibeLoco rates North Bay Shore as “Go, stay aware”.
What makes up this score?Recent news
Gogo's take on North Bay Shore
“Go with care. North Bay Shore is generally safe for everyday shopping and daytime visits, with stable residential subdivisions. However, visitors should remain alert after dark and around high-traffic commercial strips along Route 111 and Fifth Avenue.”
About the area
North Bay Shore is an unincorporated suburban hamlet in the Town of Islip, characterized by modest single-family residential neighborhoods and busy commercial corridors. Positioned between Sunrise Highway and the Southern State Parkway, it serves as a commuter hub with diverse local dining and retail.
- Suburban
- Car-Dependent
- Diverse
- Commercial Corridor
Walking and biking in North Bay Shore
Walk score: 48/100 · Bike score: 42/100
There is no public bike-share program, and cycling on major arterials like Fifth Avenue requires caution due to high speed limits and sparse dedicated bike infrastructure.
Reasons to go, and reasons to think twice
Pros
- Stable suburban residential neighborhoods with high homeownership rates
- Convenient vehicle access to major Long Island thoroughfares like Sunrise Highway and Southern State Parkway
- Low rates of violent crime within interior residential cul-de-sacs and side streets
Cons
- Higher property crime and vehicular theft rates around commercial plazas and main avenues
- Heavy vehicular traffic and high collision risk on arterial roads lacking pedestrian buffers
- Pockets of lower median income and higher poverty compared to western Long Island suburban averages
Homelessness: Visible homelessness is generally minimal throughout residential areas, with occasional individuals noticed near major bus stops and retail centers along Sunrise Highway.
What North Bay Shore is like at each time of day
- Morning · 5a – 11a
- Streets are lively with school and commuter traffic, presenting a calm and safe environment.
- Afternoon · 11a – 5p
- Plazas and major avenues are bustling with shoppers, maintaining a secure daytime atmosphere.
- Evening · 5p – 10p
- Residential blocks quiet down quickly, while dining spots along main roads stay moderately busy.
- Late night · 10p – 5a
- Foot traffic drops off considerably; it is recommended to travel by car rather than walking poorly lit streets.
Transit, parking and getting around
Suffolk County Transit operates local bus service along corridors like Fifth Avenue (Routes S41 and 3A). The nearest Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) stop is the Bay Shore station on the Montauk Branch, located approximately two miles south.
Parking is readily available and free throughout large commercial plaza lots and along most residential side streets.
Things to do in North Bay Shore
- Explore diverse Latin American, Caribbean, and Italian culinary spots along Fifth Avenue
- Shop at regional retail centers and plazas near Sunrise Highway
- Take a short drive south to Gardiner County Park and the Great South Bay waterfront
Local favorites
- Tango Argentino Steakhouse · Argentine Steakhouse · 4.5★ (840)Popular steakhouse serving traditional Argentine grilled meats, empanadas, and South American wines.
- Pasticceria Sal & Jerry's · Italian Bakery · 4.6★ (460)Classic neighborhood bakery offering fresh cannoli, Italian cookies, and specialty cakes.
- El Ranchito Mexican Restaurant · Mexican Restaurant · 4.4★ (380)Laid-back, family-owned restaurant dishing out authentic Mexican staples and homemade sauces.
Neighborhoods near North Bay Shore
Common questions about North Bay Shore
Is North Bay Shore safe to walk at night?
Mostly, on the busier, well-lit streets. Avoid empty side streets late at night.
Is North Bay Shore a good place to live?
On safety, North Bay Shore scores 70/100 — about average for the metro — most residents get by with normal city awareness.
How walkable is North Bay Shore?
Walk score 48/100 and bike score 42/100. Most trips need a car.
Which areas near North Bay Shore are safer?
Great River (92), Brightwaters (91), West Bay Shore (86) score higher nearby.
Add this score to your site
Writing about North Bay Shore? Copy this code to show its live safety score on your blog or listing.