Cities / Oyster Bay / Safest
The safest neighborhoods in Oyster Bay, NY
What makes up this score?Ranked from the 29 Oyster Bay areas we score. Top of the list means low recent crime, steady household income, and streets that stay comfortable on foot into the evening.
- 1Oyster Bay CoveOyster BayVirtually zero reported violent crime and extremely low property crime rates96Go
- 2Birchwood at JerichoOyster BayViolent crime rates are near zero and well below national benchmarks96Go
- 3Centre IslandOyster BayVirtually zero violent crime and an extremely vigilant local village police department96Go
- 4Cove NeckOyster BayNear-zero violent and property crime rates supported by high local municipal oversight96Go
- 5Upper BrookvilleOyster BayViolent crime rates are virtually zero and property crime remains significantly below national averages96Go
- 6Laurel HollowOyster BayViolent crime rates are near zero, placing the village among the safest communities in New York State96Go
- 7MuttontownOyster BayVirtually nonexistent violent crime rate supported by dedicated village police patrols96Go
- 8Brookville (Oyster Bay)Oyster BayExceptionally low violent and property crime rates well below state and national averages96Go
- 9The Hamlet on Olde Oyster BayOyster Bay24/7 gated security and virtually non-existent violent and property crime rates96Go
- 10Country Pointe at PlainviewOyster BayExceptionally low violent and property crime rates compared to national and state averages96Go
How we score
One score out of 100, weighted first on recent violent and property crime and local news, then on Census economics (income, poverty, employment), housing, education and household access measures. Walk and bike scores are shown separately so transport never inflates a safety number. Scores refresh nightly.